Why this scorecard has no 1–10 scores
A single score per country hides the one fact that can rule a country out for you. A destination can rate well overall and still refuse to treat a single woman, or ban the technique you need. So this scorecard works in two stages. First, published legal rules act as pass/fail gates. Then you weight the things that are a matter of preference. We don't score clinics or countries on quality, because we have no verified, comparable data to do that honestly.
Where the data comes from
For Europe, the gate criteria come from ESHRE's survey of IVF legislation and regulation in 43 countries (ESHRE EIM survey, Human Reproduction, 2024). The survey describes the position at 31 December 2020. It is the most complete comparable dataset available, but laws have changed in some countries since then. Spain's entries are checked against its national statute (Law 14/2006, BOE). The UK's are checked against regulator guidance (HFEA, 2016). Colombia's surrogacy entry comes from guidance by Colombia's family welfare institute, the ICBF (ICBF, 2026).
"Check" means our sources didn't confirm that point. It doesn't mean the answer is no.
Stage 1: the gate criteria
| Country | Single women | Female couples | Donor eggs | PGT-A | Surrogacy | Legal female age cap |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spain | Yes | Yes | Yes, anonymous donors | Not prohibited | No. Contracts are void | Check |
| United Kingdom | Yes | Yes | Yes, identity-release donors | Not prohibited. HFEA rates it red | Accepted | Check |
| Belgium | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not prohibited | Accepted | 45 for retrieval, 47 for transfer |
| Netherlands | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not permitted | Accepted | Check |
| Czech Republic | No | No | Yes | Not prohibited | Accepted | Check |
| Greece | Check | Check | Yes | Not prohibited | Accepted | 54 |
| Portugal | Check | Check | Yes | Not prohibited | Accepted | Check |
| France | Check | Check | Yes | Not permitted | Not among accepting countries | 42 for retrieval, 44 for transfer |
| Denmark | Check | Check | Yes | Not permitted | Not among accepting countries | 45 |
| Italy | No | No | Legal but not performed | Not prohibited | Not among accepting countries | Check |
| Germany | Check | Check | Not permitted | Not prohibited | Not among accepting countries | Check |
| Turkey | No | No | Not permitted | Not prohibited | Not among accepting countries | Check |
| Colombia | Check | Check | Check | Check | No statute. Decided case by case by the courts | Check |
| Mexico | Check | Check | Check | Check | Check | Check |
How to read the cells:
- "Not prohibited" means ESHRE listed 10 countries where PGT-A was not permitted, and this country was not one of them. It doesn't mean every clinic offers PGT-A. The HFEA rates PGT-A red in its add-ons system, meaning there are potential safety concerns or evidence that it may reduce treatment effectiveness (HFEA add-ons ratings, reviewed 2026).
- "Accepted" for surrogacy means the country was one of the 15 that ESHRE reported as accepting it. It says nothing about whether foreign intended parents can use it, or on what terms.
- "No" under single women and female couples means ESHRE reported the country as limiting treatment to heterosexual couples.
Run your situation through this table first. Any "No" in a column that applies to you removes that country from your list. Any "Check" becomes a question to put to the clinic and, for legal points, to a lawyer.
Extra gates if your plan uses donors
The main table covers the most common deal-breakers. If your plan uses donor gametes or donated embryos, add these columns from the same ESHRE survey:
- Embryo donation was unavailable in 14 countries: Austria, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Denmark, Iceland, Italy, Luxembourg, Norway, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Switzerland and Turkey.
- Double donation (donor eggs and donor sperm together) was unavailable wherever egg donation is banned, and also in Austria, Croatia, Montenegro, Norway, Serbia and Slovenia.
- Sperm donation was allowed everywhere surveyed except Bosnia and Herzegovina and Turkey.
Relationship and age conditions
Some gates concern who you are rather than what you need. ESHRE notes that Lithuania limited treatment to married couples or couples in a registered partnership. Most countries set a minimum age of 18, but Malta set 25 and Kazakhstan 19. If you are near an age limit, check whether it applies to egg retrieval, to embryo transfer, or to both. Belgium and France, for example, set different limits for each.
Turning gates into questions for clinics
Once your shortlist is down to a few countries, send every clinic the same short list of questions based on the gates. Can you treat someone in my situation? Which law or rule says so? Has anything changed since 2020? If the clinic's answer conflicts with the table, ask it to cite the current rule. Laws do change, and clinics sometimes rely on outdated assumptions too.
Stage 2: weight what's left
Once the gates have narrowed the list, the remaining differences are trade-offs, not deal-breakers. Score each shortlisted country from 1 to 5 on each criterion below, multiply by how much the criterion matters to you (also 1 to 5), and add up the totals.
| Criterion | What to look at | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| Time away and travel burden | Number of trips, flight length, time zone gap with your home clinic | The clinic's protocol calendar and your own flight search |
| Donor identity rules | Whether your child could identify the donor later, and whether that matters to you | National law. Spain is anonymous; the UK releases identity at 18 |
| Transparency of results | Whether the country has a national register of IVF outcomes, and whether the clinic reports to it | ESHRE found national IVF registers in 33 of the 43 countries surveyed |
| Embryo transfer policy | The legal cap and the clinic's own default | Spain caps transfers at three embryos per cycle. The HFEA describes single embryo transfer as usual UK practice |
| Follow-up continuity | Video consults, records in your language, a willing local doctor | The clinic's written follow-up policy |
| Price certainty | What a quote leaves out, such as medication, tests and storage | An itemised quote. The HFEA warns that low headline prices often leave these out |
Illustrative worked example
This is a hypothetical case, not a recommendation. Imagine a single woman who needs donor eggs and wants her child to be able to identify the donor later. At Stage 1, the Czech Republic, Italy and Turkey drop out because they treat only heterosexual couples. Germany and Turkey also drop out because they don't permit egg donation. Spain stays legal for her, but its donors are anonymous, which conflicts with her identity-release preference. That moves Spain from "gate" to "weighting": she must decide whether that preference is a must-have. The UK passes both gates. Belgium and the Netherlands pass the access gate, but she would need to check their donor-identity rules. Only then does she start weighting travel time and cost.
The example shows why one combined score misleads. The country that "wins" depends on which questions you ask first.
What this scorecard can't tell you
- Clinic quality. Legal frameworks are national; lab standards are set clinic by clinic. Two clinics in the same country can be very different. See our guide to vetting an IVF clinic abroad.
- Up-to-date law. The European data describes 2020. Colombia has had around 16 surrogacy bills since 1998, all shelved, and its courts keep calling on Congress to legislate, according to the ICBF. Rules there could change.
- Your home country's rules. Parentage, citizenship and importing embryos are decided at home, not in the treatment country.
- Total cost. Legal access says nothing about price. The HFEA advises comparing whole-package costs and budgeting for travel, accommodation, time off work and a contingency fund, rather than relying on a headline cycle price.
- Success rates. We left these out on purpose. Published figures are rarely comparable across countries. Our guide on reading international clinic success data explains why.
The takeaway
Use the legal gates to rule countries out, and your own weighting to choose among the rest. For a fuller decision method, pair this with our framework for comparing destinations beyond cost.
Frequently asked questions
Why doesn't this scorecard rank countries from best to worst?
Because the best country depends on the patient. A single woman, a heterosexual couple using their own eggs and a couple who need surrogacy will each be ruled out of different countries. A single ranking would put countries at the top that some readers cannot legally use.
How current is the legal information?
The European entries come from ESHRE's survey, published in 2024 and describing the position at 31 December 2020. Spain's entries were checked against its national statute and the UK's against HFEA guidance. Before you book, confirm each point with the clinic in writing. For parentage or surrogacy, also check with a lawyer.
What does 'Check' mean in the table?
It means our sources didn't confirm that point for that country. It isn't a hidden 'no'. Treat every 'Check' that matters to you as a direct question for the clinic, and ask for the answer in writing with the law or rule it is based on.
Why are Colombia and Mexico mostly 'Check'?
They aren't covered by ESHRE's European survey, and we only include points we could verify in official sources. For Colombia, the ICBF confirms there is no statute on surrogacy and that courts decide cases individually. We couldn't verify comparable official sources for Mexico, so every Mexican entry needs direct confirmation.
Should I add success rates to my own scorecard?
Only if you can compare like with like: the same age band, the same measure (live births rather than pregnancies) and the same patient group. The HFEA warns that clinics abroad sometimes show only younger patients or count pregnancies instead of births, which makes cross-country comparisons misleading.
Ready to Explore Colombia Specifically?
Tell us your situation and we'll walk you through how Colombia fits your specific priorities.
Ask Us a Question